Shared Responsibility: Why Workshop Success Depends on Everyone Playing Their Part
In this episode we tackle the persistent complaint "there are no good people anymore" and discover whether it's actually true. Andrew Uglow reveals the dual crisis facing automotive workshops: both a people shortage (quantity) and a skills shortage (quality), compounded by exponential technological change that no other trade has experienced. The discussion explores why applying financial management methodologies to human management doesn't work and why modern workers often lack foundational values and behaviors that must be actively "installed."
Andrew introduces a critical missing piece in workshop success: foremen need both high technical ability AND high people ability, yet the industry only trains for one. He unveils the Professional Foreman Method, a comprehensive training program launching October 2024 that teaches foremen how to lead people, install culture, have challenging conversations, and facilitate rather than push. The episode emphasizes that workshop success requires shared responsibility where technical excellence alone isn't enough without emotional intelligence and proper people management.
Andrew has a variety of free downloads and tools you can grab.
Discover if your workshop is Retention Worthy© here or visit his website, https://www.solutionsculture.com where the focus is on bringing reliable profitability to automotive workshop owners and workshop management through the Retention, Engagement and Development of their Technical Professionals.
This podcast was produced by 'Podcasts Done for You' https://commtogether.com.au .
Transcript
Shared responsibility.
2
:Why workshop success depends
on everyone playing their part.
3
:Join passionate automotive trainer and
coach Andrew Ulo as he examines the common
4
:technician complaint, the breakdown of
shared responsibility in modern workshops.
5
:In this episode, you'll learn why
workshop success requires both technical
6
:excellence and emotional intelligence.
7
:Discover how to create
accountability without blame.
8
:And understand why technicians and
management must share ownership
9
:of outcomes along the way, you'll
hear stories about the automotive
10
:industry's complexity and how it
demands a new approach to teamwork and
11
:why the old us versus them mentality
is killing workshop profitability.
12
:I'm your co-host Anthony Pearl, and this
is the Frictionless Workshop podcast.
13
:Let's get cranking.
14
:Andrew Uglow: Andrew.
15
:Here's my
16
:favorite
17
:Anthony Perl: quote.
18
:That you hear it in all jobs, and maybe
it's because we're getting a little bit
19
:older, but there's no good people anymore.
20
:But that specifically in an area that
is quite technical and with the scale of
21
:development that happens with cars and
managing everything to do with them these
22
:days, there's no good people anymore.
23
:That's something that comes
up all the time, isn't it?
24
:Andrew Uglow: It's funny
you should say that.
25
:And at risk of, of getting on a soapbox,
and perhaps this is why I do a podcast
26
:to, to get on a soapbox, but when you've
been doing something, anything for a long
27
:time, you start to notice patterns, right?
28
:You start to notice things recur.
29
:There's cycles to how things operate.
30
:I just looking back, when I first started
in the industry forever ago, it was really
31
:hard to find good people and then it
became, it's really hard to find people.
32
:And that then, and that's what
we were hearing from management.
33
:That's what we're hearing
from workshop owners.
34
:That's what we're hearing
from industry bodies.
35
:Oh, there's, it's really hard
to find good people, or it's
36
:really hard to find people.
37
:Now I'm hearing this
from other technicians.
38
:I, I like the people that I work with
are peanuts really not very good.
39
:Oh, I can't use the exact words
because language warnings on podcast.
40
:But they have a lot of
opportunity to improve.
41
:I, I question whether they
should be in the industry at all,
42
:let alone are they employable?
43
:It feels like a Monty Python scheme.
44
:Anthony Perl: It's not
what it was in my day.
45
:Andrew Uglow: Exactly.
46
:Um, but this is the thing, like if it
was one person, I'd just go, okay, well,
47
:you're just really unlucky to have got
a bad dude or do debt in your workplace.
48
:But when I start to hear again and
again and again from foreman, from
49
:technicians, we've got insert person.
50
:They're useless.
51
:They're absolutely useless.
52
:I end up fixing all of their problems.
53
:I end up spending all this extra
time, and I go back to the other
54
:things that we spoke about.
55
:I'm not getting paid any
more to fix their problems.
56
:I'm not getting any recognition
because of all the things that I do.
57
:So you can sort of see that these are
recurring loops and cycles within cycles.
58
:So there's this lament, you know,
where are all the good people going?
59
:Whoa.
60
:And the, the flip side is these
young people these days, you
61
:know, that's what they said
about me when I joined the trade.
62
:Young people these days,
look, they have no discipline.
63
:And you go, can track, like,
honestly, go back and track
64
:the things that tick you off.
65
:As a service manager, what are they?
66
:Okay, so we've got mistakes.
67
:Technically we've got lack of attention,
but we also got, they didn't turn
68
:up, they didn't ring me like, like
all of these basic human skills.
69
:They just disappeared at lunchtime
because they were stressed, because mental
70
:health, because in the war, in Ukraine,
because global warming, because who
71
:knows, we have rules in how we operate.
72
:We have, and these people don't
seem to fit within these rules.
73
:They don't seem to hold the same values.
74
:They don't seem to care
about their reputation.
75
:They don't seem to perceive the world
the way that we perceive the world.
76
:And so this whole idea that plays
out for that at a management level.
77
:But when we look at this
through technician lenses.
78
:This guy's getting away with everything.
79
:He does this, he doesn't do that.
80
:He should have done this, da da da da.
81
:I'm doing all the right things
and we're getting paid the same.
82
:Hang on a minute, hang on a bit.
83
:And, and so you can appreciate, you
know, what's, what's that saying?
84
:Bad company corrupts good habits.
85
:You know that if I have some optimal or
underperformers in my business that there
86
:is a a time period at which we, we, we
want to upskill them or get rid of them.
87
:Be because they will do more harm.
88
:Than not having a warm body there.
89
:And sometimes, and I know businesses that
do this, I go, I just need a warm body.
90
:Yep.
91
:They create all of this hell.
92
:But without that, I just simply
can't cope with the amount of work.
93
:'cause I don't have enough people.
94
:And the hope is that we can
find or upskill them enough,
95
:we can progress them enough.
96
:We can take them from being profoundly
suboptimal to being semi suboptimal.
97
:And that's kind of the the thing.
98
:And yet possibly.
99
:When I start hearing this from
technicians, I don't know about you,
100
:but that raises some red flags for me.
101
:The people that are working with these
people, and even if they've been in trunk,
102
:like I've had a third year apprentice come
to me and go, all of the other apprentices
103
:in my workshop are just horrendous.
104
:I, I dunno why they put them on.
105
:Okay.
106
:That I don't know about you, but
it's, that throws up a whole variety
107
:of questions and red flags for me.
108
:And so going back to the testing, the idea
is there in fact no good people anymore.
109
:You know, the frustration of
working with not good people,
110
:you know, where have all the good
people got young people these days?
111
:All of those versions of that claim.
112
:Is it true?
113
:And I'm gonna go, yeah,
it's true without question.
114
:Don't just have a skill shortage in
terms of the number of people available.
115
:The people that we have
also don't have the skills.
116
:So we have, if you like, we have
a people shortage and we have a
117
:skills that people don't have.
118
:Shortage or issue.
119
:And so it's a two part thing.
120
:And so is there a drop in quality
of talent in the workshops?
121
:I'm gonna go, yeah.
122
:Yeah, there is.
123
:And you, you take that idea and then
you layer over the non incremental,
124
:the massive exponential change in
technology that's come through cars.
125
:And even if you go back 10 years,
you know what's changed for plumbers?
126
:What's changed for carpenters?
127
:What's changed for.
128
:Air conditioning techs, what's changed?
129
:Like sure there's changes, but nothing
like the automotive industry has seen.
130
:Like nothing.
131
:Nothing at all.
132
:And so not only do we now have
people that perhaps don't have
133
:the people skills, don't have the
values, don't have the comprehension.
134
:If they've come from another part of
the world, perhaps they don't share the
135
:same ideals and the same concepts of
what's acceptable and what's not for us.
136
:And we see that a lot too,
that it's not just a people
137
:clash, it's a cultural clash.
138
:That's a whole nother
kettle of fish, right?
139
:There's, there's a whole
nother level of skill.
140
:If I'm a manager slash leader,
how do I lead through that?
141
:We have that, but we also
have the change in technology.
142
:And I'm again, automotive tragic.
143
:Well, automotive life, I had the benefit
of seeing this incremental change.
144
:We went from cars being largely mechanical
systems to, with a few electrical
145
:circuits, you know, lights and charging
systems, and spark ignition and stuff.
146
:To cars being an entirely networked
vehicle, highly networked vehicle
147
:with a few mechanical components.
148
:Yeah, we still got brakes.
149
:Yeah,
150
:Anthony Perl: we have an
electric motor now that does the,
151
:hopefully we still got brakes.
152
:Andrew Uglow: Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
153
:That's a trivial detail.
154
:We have mechanical doors
that still open and close.
155
:You know, they aren't curtains
or force fields or something
156
:that keep us in the car.
157
:We haven't gone that far yet, but like
there's, there's a few mechanical things
158
:in the car, but it's now an electronic
device with a few mechanical bits.
159
:And so I've seen that
change gradually over time.
160
:But for people who step into the industry
today, like that's like, like drinking
161
:from a fire hose, you know, wrapping
your lips around the end of that nozzle
162
:and turning that, turning that hose
on high, it's a lot of information
163
:to get down at a really short space
of time, and so that just compounds
164
:what the individual is experiencing.
165
:Trying to find their feet in an industry
and underperforming while they do it.
166
:Anthony Perl: The Frictionless
Workshop Podcast is brought
167
:to you by Solutions Culture.
168
:For details on how to get in touch
with Andrew, consult the show notes
169
:below, and don't forget to subscribe
so you don't miss an episode.
170
:Now back to the podcast.
171
:They're being trained on a
completely new way of doing
172
:things and a new type of engine.
173
:So their experience is
always going to be different.
174
:So they're not gonna make
'em like they used to because
175
:they can't and they shouldn't.
176
:Andrew Uglow: Right.
177
:And so if we dive into this and we start
to look at things a little bit deeper
178
:than the surface level, and usually
this is expressed in frustration.
179
:I've gotta fix up all this person's screw
ups, I've gotta, I'm constantly holding
180
:their hand and wiping up after them.
181
:Um, there's two big
chunks that are at play.
182
:The first chunk is the environment
that they're working in.
183
:People respond to the
environment they're working in.
184
:And if I've got a suboptimal environment,
if I'm not, if I'm applying financial
185
:management methodologies to humans,
I'm never gonna get a good result.
186
:I just can, it's not possible.
187
:So I need to have leadership.
188
:I need to have a, an environment that
that is suitable for humans, suitable for
189
:people that considers those people things.
190
:Sure I have to make a profit.
191
:Don't get me wrong, they're
parallel, but I just, I find that
192
:the environment that often these people
find themselves in is not useful.
193
:It doesn't serve, it doesn't help
the business, doesn't customers, and
194
:certainly doesn't help the individual.
195
:The second element is the reality is
that people today aren't the same.
196
:They just aren't.
197
:Different culture, different world.
198
:Like we, we talk about people being tech
dependent, as in technology dependent.
199
:Like I remember a long time ago
on a galaxy far away, when there
200
:was no internet, we never had it.
201
:We, you were left to your own devices
to be resourceful to figure it out.
202
:Now, I just asked Chad, Hey
Chad, how do I fix this car?
203
:Oh, well Andrew, you need
to da da da da da da.
204
:And it may or may not be correct.
205
:Like's been known to hallucinate
once or twice before.
206
:And if I give it bad information,
I get a bad response back.
207
:And so now it's chat's fault, not mine.
208
:But the reality is that people don't
have the same foundations, that
209
:the, the behaviors that we see are
symptoms of things that aren't there.
210
:And so the reality is, if I
want this person to perform, I'm
211
:gonna have to do the install.
212
:It's like complaining that my car
didn't come with leather seats.
213
:Well, okay, so it doesn't
come with leather seats.
214
:If you want leather seats, you're
gonna have to put them in yourself.
215
:You want the people to hold these values,
you're gonna have to install them.
216
:That's the reality.
217
:It sucks to be you.
218
:Sure, but that's the reality.
219
:If you want this, you're
gonna have to do the work.
220
:And so this becomes a problem because one,
we don't have in the industry, we don't
221
:have good systems and processes for doing
the install, or we put them through an
222
:apprenticeship and that does some work.
223
:That's good, that's useful,
but it's incomplete.
224
:It's insufficient.
225
:We certainly don't have any mechanism.
226
:For doing the install for these values
and skills and behaviors and stuff.
227
:We have compliance, but that's like
using a hammer to fix everything.
228
:You know?
229
:That's not gonna work well.
230
:We don't have any training for people
in the business for how to do this.
231
:We don't have any industry wide things
that develop this, that look at people and
232
:go, look, this is how we need to operate.
233
:If you wanna work in this
environment, you need these skills.
234
:So let's go and develop those
skills and the people skills,
235
:not the technical skills.
236
:Sure, we do technical skills
really well, but we just don't
237
:do the other side really well.
238
:So,
239
:you know, back to this complaint,
we can either keep banging our head
240
:against the wall and having a Sooky
lala moment over it and complaining, oh,
241
:you, I'm gonna, or we can suck it up.
242
:We can go, okay, so they don't have this,
how am I gonna get the, get that to them?
243
:And we get the pushback.
244
:Oh, well they don't want to,
they don't this, they don't.
245
:Yeah.
246
:Okay.
247
:That's all very external.
248
:What are you gonna do about it?
249
:You know, who's got two thumbs
and holds of responsibility here?
250
:Well, that's leadership,
that's management.
251
:So if you are the service
manager, you are the foreman.
252
:This is on you.
253
:And if we go back historically
and look at how Foreman did, sure.
254
:They were the technical gurus.
255
:They were the knowledge holders.
256
:They were the problem solvers.
257
:They were the ones that did stuff,
but they also led the culture.
258
:And we don't train them
how to do that anymore.
259
:That's gone.
260
:Foreman is Andrew, how much longer Andrew?
261
:Customers waiting.
262
:Andrew, why isn't that job done?
263
:We have this whole financial framework
over managing people, and it just sucks.
264
:Just it's awful.
265
:It's inappropriate.
266
:It's like using a hammer to fix
everything and sure, there's
267
:things that need a hammer.
268
:There's things that need a hammer and a.
269
:There's also a need finesse.
270
:Things that don't need a hammer.
271
:Anthony Perl: How you sell
it in is everything, right?
272
:And the funny thing is, they know how
to do that when it comes to the car.
273
:It's how they do it with the individual.
274
:Because, you know, we were talking
before, um, you know, come in and you
275
:go, okay, say to me you need new breaks.
276
:Now if they say you need new breaks,
but you need it in the next six months.
277
:He's very different to the urgency
of saying, look, your breaks
278
:are down to the final bits.
279
:You need to get your breaks
done in the next week.
280
:Otherwise you risk having
a serious accident.
281
:Andrew Uglow: Yeah.
282
:Anthony Perl: And selling it to me that
way goes, okay, let's do the breaks now.
283
:Let's get onto it.
284
:I can't put this off.
285
:And it's the same way that you have to
deal with technicians in wanting them to
286
:develop and do more things along the way.
287
:It's how you sell it into them.
288
:When you get that complaint saying
that you're just banging your head
289
:against a brick wall, that they're
not really that interested how you
290
:sell it might be the key to, uh,
what the response is from them.
291
:Andrew Uglow: Sure.
292
:Uh, I'm gonna offer, what we have
is, if you imagine two axes, right?
293
:The first axe is technical.
294
:Technical skill.
295
:Technical ability.
296
:I like the word ability better.
297
:'cause ability is skill
times knowledge, right?
298
:It's what I can actually produce.
299
:So we have this machine that over
time produces technical ability.
300
:Okay?
301
:So if we look at the scale of things
and where we expect our people to be, we
302
:expect them to be high technical ability.
303
:And so that's efficiency, that's
professionalism, that's fixed visits,
304
:all those metrics that we track.
305
:Conversely, for leadership, we don't
have really, we have management
306
:as the other horizontal, and
it's kind of one or the other.
307
:We have high management skill
or high technical ability.
308
:And if we zoom in and go back to the idea
of, well, who's responsible for this?
309
:Sure.
310
:It's the management.
311
:Without question, management of
the business, management of the
312
:workshop, without question, the
buck stops with them and well, what
313
:have they put in place to do this?
314
:Because the service manager's got a
thousand different things to manage.
315
:And putting out fires and doing all the
stuff that they do well, what system have
316
:we got in place to, to look after this?
317
:And there's some stuff and there's
some leadership that, that we see
318
:coming through when I go, you know,
80, 20, 20% of businesses do this.
319
:Well, 80%.
320
:Not yet.
321
:I go back into the piece
that's missing in all this.
322
:The piece that's been overlooked in
all this is the foreman who has the
323
:face time with the technicians, the
foreman who has the influence with the
324
:technicians, the foreman who has the
ability to do the install of the values
325
:and the behaviors and the methods, and
the way we roll the cultural things.
326
:Well, that's the foreman's job.
327
:Sure, they have the technical
responsibility as well, but we've never
328
:trained them to do the people part.
329
:We've never given them.
330
:People ability.
331
:We've given them technical ability.
332
:We've never given them people ability.
333
:And so this is one of the things like I,
I feel like I'm on my soapbox all over
334
:again, but this is one of the things
that confounds me is why haven't we
335
:trained our foreman on how to do this?
336
:Okay, we expect high technical
ability yet great, but that's
337
:not their role, and that's.
338
:That alone is not their role.
339
:And using them for that
is to underutilize them.
340
:The reality is we should be teaching
them to how to influence people,
341
:how to deal with the human side of
things, how to install values, how
342
:to install culture, how to install
professionalism, how to do micro learning.
343
:So that, and again, I get back to the
idea that I get feedback from Foreman,
344
:I've told him again and again and again.
345
:Okay, so you keep telling
him, telling isn't working.
346
:What else should you do?
347
:And they look at me blankly.
348
:'cause they don't have anything else.
349
:No one's explained to them.
350
:This is how you install information
into someone who doesn't have it.
351
:That they don't have a framework
for that they don't have, they
352
:don't have a tactic for that.
353
:They don't even have
good practice for that.
354
:We just what?
355
:Just get outta hammer and start banging.
356
:We're surprising, we're not going,
357
:Anthony Perl: we, and how often is it is
that people could just keep explaining
358
:the same thing in the same way, and
that's not going to make it any clearer
359
:for someone who doesn't know you.
360
:You have to change your approach to
how you're delivering that information
361
:and the, and the explanation and
the information you make available
362
:to them to be able to learn.
363
:Otherwise, you're just repeating.
364
:Andrew Uglow: And, and I go
back to what's your goal here?
365
:Like really as a business,
what's your outcome?
366
:Are you just there to make money?
367
:Well, we've been doing that for decades
and look at the state of their people.
368
:And I, I think that we need to
perhaps have a good hard look.
369
:And this plays right up and down.
370
:The idea of leadership
is have a good hard look.
371
:'cause if we don't take care of
people, no one else is going to.
372
:We can't expect people to come
into our business with all the
373
:pieces that we want them to have.
374
:That doesn't exist anymore.
375
:And so we can so about it and go, oh,
this and all that, and we can cycle
376
:through people and we can invest a million
dollars plus a year on staff turn if
377
:we want to, or maybe we could invest
less than that and start to work about
378
:developing the people side of things
and make that part of people's KPI.
379
:Hey look Anthony, we want you
to learn how to manage people.
380
:We want you to learn how to.
381
:In install culture, we want you
to learn how to do micro learning.
382
:Anthony, we want you to be able to manage
customers as part of your role as a, a
383
:senior tech or a foreman or a controller.
384
:Andrew, we want you to be
able to lead millennials.
385
:Well, let's, let me show you how
you do that because until we do,
386
:I, I don't know about you, but I
just see a self repeating cycle.
387
:I see the same complaint that we've
been banging on about for 30 years.
388
:Plus happening again
389
:Anthony Perl: and again and again.
390
:I mean, I think if you were to jump
in a time machine and go back 30 or
391
:40 years and you were to have this
conversation with them, they'd probably
392
:be saying exactly the same thing.
393
:Oh, we just can't get good people anymore.
394
:It's a story that we've been telling.
395
:For so long that it almost becomes
compulsory to tell the story
396
:rather than to address the problem.
397
:Andrew Uglow: Right?
398
:It's, yeah, it's easier to have a
complaint than it is to, what is it?
399
:I must do Something always achieves
more than something must be done, and
400
:so I've taken this very personally.
401
:Anthony, just as we wrap up this idea.
402
:This is not a small trivial thing for me.
403
:This has been burning my butt for years.
404
:Like how do we solve this problem?
405
:How do we get around this?
406
:How do we facilitate outstanding
financial performance for businesses
407
:when all of the things are tightening?
408
:'cause they are like, pick one.
409
:This is what I'm saying about automotive.
410
:If you can be successful in automotive
with everything stacked against you and
411
:still be successful, what can't you do?
412
:So given that environment, how do we.
413
:Run better.
414
:How do we operate better?
415
:How do we, given that it's all the things
that it is, how do we do that well?
416
:And ultimately it comes
down to the technicians.
417
:In any workshop, the quality of my
technicians are directly proportional
418
:to the profitability of my business.
419
:Sure, I need good, efficient management.
420
:Sure, I need great systems.
421
:Sure I need great customer service people.
422
:That all helps amplify
what the technicians do.
423
:But if I don't have
good techs, I'm nowhere.
424
:I go back to, well, whose job is
it not to train the technicians?
425
:Whose job is it to
develop the technicians?
426
:And that goes back to the service
manager and more specifically,
427
:it goes back to the foreman.
428
:Sure, we want foreman that are high
technical without question, but we
429
:need them to be high people as well.
430
:And we get that by training
them and there's nothing.
431
:There is absolutely zero.
432
:I can send them to TAFE and they can
do a cert four and workplace leadership
433
:or workplace business management or
workplace, you know, whatever it is.
434
:And okay, nice piece of paper.
435
:And they'll learn some stuff,
but it doesn't cut the mustard.
436
:It's not what they need.
437
:And so I've gone and doubled down on this.
438
:I have far out, I have invested enormous
amounts of time, research, energy.
439
:The reason I know all these complaints
is I've been testing this over years
440
:with people, and so I've developed
essentially what is a foreman school?
441
:How do you get your foreman up
in the scale of people ability or
442
:you send them to foreman school?
443
:Well, you would send them to trade
school to learn the technical.
444
:Well send them to foreman school to
learn the other side, the people side.
445
:And so we've developed a, a program
called the Professional Foreman Method,
446
:literally right about to launch.
447
:So this is, if you're watching this
or listening to this, this is October.
448
:Early October, we plan to be
launching by the end of the
449
:month and taking enrollments for,
how do you train your foreman?
450
:Well, this is how you train your foreman.
451
:This is, I'm gonna argue the first
time that I know of that there is a
452
:foreman school that we teach foreman
and controllers how to manage people,
453
:not how to manage business, not
how to manage technical ability.
454
:We'll help with that for sure, but
this is how to manage people how
455
:to, or better how to lead people.
456
:How to install the culture, how to have
the challenging conversations, how to get
457
:these millennials to do what you want them
to do, or what if they wanted to do it?
458
:Wouldn't that be easier?
459
:Wouldn't that be a better solution?
460
:Instead of me pushing these people,
wouldn't it be better if I led them,
461
:if I facilitated them doing their job?
462
:Wouldn't that be a far more
sensible way to approach this?
463
:Instead of push, push, push,
push, bang, bang, bang with a
464
:hammer because it's not working.
465
:What we're doing now positively is not.
466
:I sure we get some results,
but gee whiz, for what effort?
467
:What time, what cost.
468
:Anthony Perl: Thank you for listening
to the Frictionless Workshop podcast.
469
:For details on how to get Andrew
working with you and your technicians.
470
:Take a look at the show notes.
471
:There's also a link to some
special content you can access.
472
:I'm Anthony Pearl reminding you to
subscribe so you don't miss an episode.